How to Fix Unpaid Overtime: Self-Audits and the PAID Program
To fix unpaid overtime, run a self-audit of your time and pay records, calculate what each employee is owed week by week, pay the back wages and change the practice that caused the gap. You can pay employees directly, or use the Wage and Hour Division's PAID program, which supervises the payment so that employees who accept it release their federal FLSA claims for the violations covered. PAID does not release state law claims, and it is closed to employers already under investigation or in litigation over the same practice.
This guide walks through the self-audit, a back pay calculation, how PAID works and what it leaves open. This guide is general information, not legal advice. Rules change and vary by state, so confirm your situation with an employment attorney or your state labor department, ideally before you contact the WHD or pay anyone, because the route you choose changes what employees release.
Step 1: Set the scope of the self-audit
Decide which practices, which employees and which period you will review. The FLSA lookback is 2 years, or 3 for willful violations, and PAID covers violations within the last 2 years. Some states reach further back: New York allows wage claims for 6 years, as explained in New York wage and hour rules.
Most unpaid overtime comes from a short list of practices, so test each one:
- Hours not combined across two locations or two jobs in the same workweek.
- Rounding that favors the employer, such as always rounding clock-ins forward (see time clock rounding rules).
- Work before or after the shift, or calls and messages after hours (see off-the-clock work).
- Overtime cut from timesheets because a manager did not approve it (see unauthorized overtime).
- Bonuses and shift differentials left out of the regular rate (see how to calculate the regular rate).
- Meal breaks deducted automatically even when they were interrupted (see automatic meal break deductions).
Step 2: Compare time records with payroll
For each employee in scope, line up three things for every workweek: the original punches or timesheets, the hours paid in payroll, and the pay rate with any bonuses or differentials. A difference between hours worked and hours paid, or a premium computed on the wrong rate, is a finding.
Work from the original entries, not from edited totals. If your time clock keeps an edit history, check which edits reduced hours and why. Where records are missing, write down how you estimated the hours, for example from schedules, door badge data or register logins, because the WHD and any court will ask.
Keep one worksheet line per employee per workweek: hours worked, hours paid, regular rate, premium owed, premium paid and the difference. That worksheet is your calculation, your evidence of good faith and, if you use PAID, the core of what you submit.
Step 3: Calculate the back wages
The formula depends on what was missed:
- Hours over 40 that were never paid at all: owed at 1.5 times the regular rate.
- Hours over 40 paid at straight time: only the half-time premium is missing, 0.5 times the regular rate.
- Unpaid hours in a week under 40: the FLSA only guarantees that the week averages at least the minimum wage, but state wage laws and your pay agreement generally require the agreed rate for every hour, so most employers pay them at that rate.
Example: a business with two stores finds that three employees picked up shifts at both stores. Each store kept its own timesheets and nobody added the hours together, so every hour was paid at straight time but no one received an overtime premium. Because straight time was already paid, each hour over 40 is owed the half-time premium:
| Employee | Hourly rate | Premium per hour (0.5 x rate) | Hours over 40 per affected week | Affected weeks | Back wages |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | $18.00 | $9.00 | 4 | 80 | 80 x 4 x $9.00 = $2,880.00 |
| B | $16.50 | $8.25 | 6 | 52 | 52 x 6 x $8.25 = $2,574.00 |
| C | $21.00 | $10.50 | 3 | 104 | 104 x 3 x $10.50 = $3,276.00 |
| Total | $8,730.00 |
A real self-audit computes every workweek from the records; the averages here keep the example short. If an employee's rate differs between the two stores, the premium is based on the weighted average rate for that week, as shown in overtime for employees with two pay rates.
Compare what the same finding can cost in court. If the employees sue and win, liquidated damages add an equal amount, so $8,730.00 becomes $17,460.00 before their attorney fees, and a willful finding stretches the lookback to 3 years, which adds weeks. We walk through that math in wage and hour lawsuits and back pay.
Back wages are taxed as wages in the year you pay them (IRS Publication 957), so run them through payroll and report them on that year's W-2.
Step 4: Pay directly or through PAID
Paying directly corrects the underpayment quickly, but a private payment is not a release. FLSA rights generally cannot be waived by private agreement, so an employee who accepts the check can still sue, including for liquidated damages. A payment supervised by the WHD is different: under 29 U.S.C. 216(c), an employee who accepts it in full waives the right to sue for those unpaid wages and the matching liquidated damages.
Timing matters. The WHD says employers who have already paid the back wages before applying are not eligible for PAID, and a payment made before the WHD reviews it does not waive employees' right to sue. Decide on the route before any money goes out.
How the PAID program works
The Payroll Audit Independent Determination (PAID) program started in 2018 and was relaunched on July 24, 2025. According to the WHD's PAID page, it covers potential FLSA minimum wage, overtime and tip retention violations, and certain FMLA violations. The steps are:
- Self-audit. Identify the violations, the affected employees and the time period, and calculate the back wages.
- Report to the WHD. Submit your findings, calculations and records with a certification that you meet the program's requirements.
- WHD review. The WHD evaluates the submission and, if it accepts, sends a summary of unpaid wages and the proposed scope of the release.
- Payment. Pay 100% of the back wages due within 15 days of receiving the summary, and send the WHD proof of payment.
Each employee decides whether to accept. An employee who accepts releases federal claims only for the violations listed in the WHD's acceptance letter; an employee who declines keeps the right to sue, and you may not retaliate against that choice. Since Field Assistance Bulletin 2025-3 (June 27, 2025), the WHD does not supervise liquidated damages in administrative matters, and its PAID guidance says participants are not required to pay civil money penalties.
Who cannot use PAID
The WHD reviews each request case by case, and an employer is not eligible when:
- the WHD or a court found a minimum wage or overtime violation against it in the last 3 years;
- it used PAID for FLSA issues in the last 3 years;
- the practices are in litigation, whether a private lawsuit or a case with the WHD or a state agency;
- the WHD is already investigating those practices, to the employer's knowledge;
- the employees are covered by prevailing wage requirements (Davis-Bacon and Related Acts, the Service Contract Act, or the H-1B, H-2A or H-2B programs);
- it already paid the back wages before applying.
You must also disclose recent employee complaints about the practices and commit to future compliance.
What PAID does not cover
- State and local claims. The WHD cannot supervise payments or provide releases for state law violations, and PAID does not cut off employee rights under state or local law. Settle state claims separately where state law allows it.
- Other violations and periods. The release is limited to what the acceptance letter lists.
- Future investigations. PAID does not waive the WHD's right to investigate you later, and if the review turns up other issues, the WHD will ordinarily try to resolve them in the same audit.
- Confidentiality. Your self-audit is subject to the same Freedom of Information Act rules as any WHD investigation.
If an investigator is already asking for records, PAID is no longer an option; see DOL wage and hour audit for how that process works.
Fix the cause so it does not come back
A payment without a process change sets up a repeat finding, and continuing a practice after you know it is wrong is what turns a mistake into a willful violation with a 3-year lookback. Write down what changed: hours combined across locations every workweek, no rounding or rounding you can show is neutral, a written rule that all time worked is recorded and paid, and an exception review before each payroll run.
How SimpleWorkshift Helps You Find and Prevent Unpaid Overtime
A self-audit is only as good as the original records. SimpleWorkshift keeps every clock-in and clock-out from the iOS or Android app or the web, with a GPS location, and every edit logs who changed it, when, and the original value, so you can see exactly which changes reduced hours. Records stay available for at least 3 years, even after an employee's account is deactivated.
Custom reports show hours per employee per pay period, overtime and break deductions, export to CSV or PDF for your worksheet, and alerts as employees approach 40 hours help you keep the problem from coming back. Try it free for 30 days, with no contracts, at simpleworkshift.com.